Skip directly to content

This Day in 1939: The Spanish Civil War Ends

on Sun, 04/01/2012 - 16:21

On April 1, 1939 the Spanish Civil War finally ended after three bloody years that had left the idea of post World War I European peace, such as it was, in tatters and only further destabilized a continent that had never really put the ghosts of the First World War behind it.

The Spanish Civil War had begun on July 17, 1936, when rebels in Spanish Morocco, calling themselves The Nationalists and led by Francisco Franco, initiated an insurgency designed to overthrow the Popular Front government of the Spanish Republic. The Nationalists espoused fascist ideology similar to that found in Germany and Italy – each of whom not unsurprisingly provided ample support to their ideological brethren in Spain. The Republicans, or Loyalists, meanwhile had successfully lobbied for help from the Soviet Union and the new Popular Front Socialist government in France.

The war, in addition to causing horrendous civilian casualties as well as being marked by numerous atrocities, served as an important proving ground for, in particular, those European states most responsible for plunging Europe into a continent wide war – Germany and the Soviet Union. Of the two it is not a stretch to argue that Germany benefited the most from its experiences in Spain. The German military contingent, named the Condor Legion, featured many of Germany’s future wartime officers. These officers rotated through the Legion in short tours lasting no more than several months at a time. Although brief, these tours of duty provided critical experience for the participating German soldiers. Both Mussolini and Hitler, signed pacts with Franco whereby Spain provided economic aid and natural resources to Germany and Italy in exchange for military assistance for the Nationalists. Germany secured considerable quantities of iron ore, critical for fueling the booming economic expansion and rearming German military.

The British and French, instead of sending direct aid, ever fearful of general European war, acted to stop the war from spreading by declaring a non-intervention policy. Both Germany and Italy publicly signed on to the associated treaty late in 1936, but covertly aided the Nationalists anyway.  The Soviet Union served as the prime Republican benefactor, and although volunteers from Britain, France, and the United States all served with the Republicans - it was not enough.  Fascist military assistance helped Franco defeat the Republicans and consolidate his power early in the spring of 1939.  Two years prior to the Republican defeat however, as if there was any doubt regarding what National Socialism would mean, Germany displayed its true colors to the outside world in an event, since memorialized for eternity by the artist Pablo Picasso (see image), occurring at an unassuming Spanish town named Guernica.

The small town of Guernica sat within the Basque region in northwest Spain; a region falling within range of the Spanish Civil War’s front lines. By April 26, 1937 Guernica’s population of 7,000 people had swelled with war refugees seeking shelter from the combatants battling just over the horizon, only miles from the town. In spite of the thousands of refugees packing the town the German Condor Legion swept over Guernica, dropping over 40 tons of bombs. The Condor Legion’s pilots then ruthlessly winged above, repeatedly strafing the devastated town; leaving over one thousand dead civilians in their wake. The Spanish Civil War, and atrocities such as Guernica, markedly raised the political temperature in Europe. Of course Hitler welcomed the winds of war; sensing the opportunity to begin the racial struggle he had long since viewed as Germany’s destiny.

Comments

Lt. Colonel Robert A. Lynn, Florida Guard's picture

It has been a long held belief among many individuals and historians that it was the Condor Legion that had bombed Guernica but new research and scholarship in recent years have come to light to challenge that long held historical viewpoint. Reporting on a visit to Guernica, The Times military correspondnt wrote the following on 5 May 1937: "That Guernica after a week's bombardment by aircraft and artillery shouldn't have shown signs of fire supports the Nationalist contention that aicraft weren't responsible for the burning of the town, which was bombed intermittently for a period of two hours. In Guernica, few fragments of bombs have been recovered, the facades of buildings still standing are unmarked, and the few craters I inspected were larger than anything hitherto made by a bomb in Spain. From their position, it is fair inference that these craters werecaused by exploding mines which were nscirntifically laid to cut roads."

A further unidentified srce echoed this: "What actually happened was that industrial Basques, miners from Asturias, experts n explosives, fired and dynamited the town according to a pre-arranged plan. Two French artillery officers, vetrans of World War I, inspected the town when Franco's troops entered. What they saw was, they said, largely the result of arson and incendiarism. Petrol had been largelyused, plus dynamite. Each alleged 'bomb' crater coincided with a sewer-manhole on the street, and where there had been no sewers, there had been no 'bombs'.

And Sir Arnold Wilson, Conservative member of Parliament for Hitchin, Hertfordshire, wrote to The Observer after a visit to Guernica, on 3 October 1937: "There was no evidence of damage from aerial bombardment, he said, but "most if not all of the damage was caused by wilful (spelling) incendiarism and such is the verdict of the inhabitants." Sir Arnold was convincedthat Guernica was a "p-up ob," a Communist atrocitystory calulated to recoil on Franco and the Germans.

Thousands wee said to have been killed by the bombs. This version of history-no surprises here-has been uncritically adopted ever since by conformist historianswho have carried out no original research. The Spanish artist Pablo Picasso, a Communist multi-millionaire, commemorated the raid in a famous propaganda painting titled "Guernica". Its on display in the United Nations building and the original and sketches are displayed in a gallery in Madrid. Closer examination reveals the Picasso painting to be a surrealist depiction of a bullfight; his first sketches for it are found in his notebooks dating back over one year before the raid.

Further evidence is provided in Luis Bolin's memoir of the Spanish Civil War, SPAIN: THE VITAL YEARS in which he discusses the Guernica controversy. He flew General Franco to Spain at the start of the war. Also, the local registry of births and deaths lists 98 deaths from the air raid (most of them killed in one incident on a shelter near the local asylum, the Hospital-Asilo Calzada) and the local Communist newspaper Euzkadi Roja, publishing a report on the raid on 28 April 1937, which included a list of names of those injured in the attack.

Respectfully Submitted-Lt. Colonel Robert A. Lynn, Florida Guard   

SteveMerc's picture

Thank you for your very interesting post.

I must say that to date I have seen no credible evidence suggesting that anyone other than the German Luftwaffe's Condor Legion and some elements of the Italian Aviazione Legionaria were primarily responsible for the destruction in Guernica during the spring of 1937.

If you have any further information from primary sources or respected secondary sources then I think I speak for our readers in as much as we would love to see it.

If anyone else has anything to add on this please don't be afraid to contribute.

Steven Mercatante

Post new comment